Preview prototyped
OK, an initial implementation of my preview required functionality is complete. Other than requiring a preview, most of you should not see any different behavior. I've also relaxed my spam throttle to allow three comments - this allows the first to go through and two warnings before someone is temporarily shut down.
Now I plan to watch and see what action is warranted next.
Your mandatory preview works quite well. I really like it. I'm sure I will have fewer typos in a system like this.
Posted by Scott Johnson at
I'd like to see a self moderated system, where readers vote on comments, so anything of poor quality (SPAM, etc...) just "goes away". Kinda like the /. moderation.
Posted by homer jay at
If you want /., you could just post on /. (or k5 for that matter), or run slashcode on your own blog. Sam already moderates comments, I doubt that he wants his readers doing their own moderation.
Posted by Gordon Weakliem at
Dates, times, and blog entry ids for the spams received so far this year:
Jan 1 09:06 1060 Jan 1 09:38 1477 Jan 2 03:03 1430 Jan 2 04:42 1428 Jan 3 02:26 1430 Jan 3 03:19 1053 Jan 3 03:21 1053 Jan 3 03:25 1047 Jan 3 03:29 1037 Jan 3 03:52 1428 Jan 3 03:59 1299 Jan 3 04:02 1394 Jan 3 04:07 1336 Jan 3 04:10 1582 Jan 3 04:12 1583 Jan 3 04:17 1585 Jan 3 04:20 1587 Jan 3 04:22 1588 Jan 3 06:28 1572 Jan 3 07:22 1472 Jan 4 11:28 1640 Jan 4 11:32 1638 Jan 5 14:30 1089 Jan 6 06:54 1666 Jan 7 09:15 1472 Jan 7 23:54 1682 Jan 8 01:00 1345 Jan 8 06:46 1472Posted by Sam Ruby at
Cool!
Very similar to the solution I've been using for a while now. But my hidden field uses an SHA1 hash and nonce, making it a little harder to circumvent.
Posted by Jacques Distler atSpam Update
Based on the lively discussions of the past few days, it certainly appears that requiring a preview does not impede the flow of discussion. Cool. Spam also is way down, despite my having removed and relaxed a number of other defenses. Notably, my spa... [more]Trackback from Sam Ruby at
Hmm, every spam count > 2 per day seems too much.
Best thing would be zero, but this day will never come :(
Posted by Dirk at
Testing to see what Sam has up his sleeve....
Posted by Steve Mallett at